What the guide clarifies
- The rationale justifies the source material, contexts (local or global) and areas of inquiry; the commentary explains how the experiments evolved.
IB Music has two internal assessments. Experimenting with music, at SL and HL, is an experimentation report with creating and performing audio excerpts, marked on criteria A–D out of 28 (30% at SL, 20% at HL). The contemporary music maker, HL only, is a multimedia presentation of a real-life music project, marked on its own criteria A–D out of 32 (30%).
Updated 2026-11-09
| Criterion | Marks | What it assesses |
|---|---|---|
| A. Rationale and commentary: creating | 6 | Whether the rationale for creating experiments is persuasive and the commentary explains the process and musical decisions. |
| B. Practical experiments: creating | 8 | Whether the three creating excerpts transform the source material through informed musical decisions. |
| C. Rationale and commentary: performing | 6 | As criterion A, applied to the performing experiments. |
| D. Practical experiments: performing | 8 | As criterion B, applied to the three performing excerpts. |
| HL A. Selection of evidence | 8 | HL music maker: whether the evidence chosen to document the project is appropriate and well chosen. |
| HL B. Discussion of the process | 12 | How you discuss challenges and successes, areas for development and your musical and collaborative choices against the project's aims. |
| HL C. Technical and musical proficiency in the role | 8 | Your technical proficiency and musicianship in your identified role in the final product. |
| HL D. Organization and presentation | 4 | How well the multimedia presentation is organized and presented. |
| Total | Experimenting 28 · HL project 32 |
The first four criteria are Experimenting with music (SL and HL); the last four are the contemporary music maker (HL only).
Based on the IB Music guide (first assessment 2022), internal assessment criteria. Band descriptions are summarised in our own words; follow the official guide your school provides.
Whether the rationale for creating experiments is persuasive and the commentary explains the process and musical decisions.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Ineffective rationale; process outlined with rudimentary decisions. |
| 3–4 | Suitable rationale; process described with reasonable decisions. |
| 5–6 | Purposeful rationale; process explained with relevant decisions. |
Reaching the top band: Write each decision as a chain (what you found in the source, what you tried, what happened, what you did next) with exact bar numbers or timings.
Whether the three creating excerpts transform the source material through informed musical decisions.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Reiterates the source; limited development; superficial evidence of decisions. |
| 3–4 | Recreates the source; formulaic development; inconsistent evidence. |
| 5–6 | Adapts the source; purposeful development; proficient evidence. |
| 7–8 | Transforms the source; imaginative development; compelling evidence. |
Reaching the top band: Order the three excerpts as a line of development, from close to the source, through your changes, to something clearly transformed.
As criterion A, applied to the performing experiments.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Ineffective rationale; rudimentary decisions. |
| 3–4 | Suitable rationale; reasonable decisions. |
| 5–6 | Purposeful rationale; relevant decisions explained. |
Reaching the top band: Show what research lay behind each performing choice, such as tempo, tone, ornamentation or improvisation, and how it changed your playing.
As criterion B, applied to the three performing excerpts.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Reiterates; limited; superficial. |
| 3–4 | Recreates; formulaic; inconsistent. |
| 5–6 | Adapts; purposeful; proficient. |
| 7–8 | Transforms; imaginative; compelling. |
Reaching the top band: Make the differences audible, for example the same passage handled three ways, and explain each change in the report.
HL music maker: whether the evidence chosen to document the project is appropriate and well chosen.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Ineffective or rudimentary selection. |
| 3–4 | Suitable but formulaic. |
| 5–6 | Relevant and purposeful. |
| 7–8 | Resourceful and compelling. |
Reaching the top band: Choose only the evidence that shows key turning points, each narrated in relation to your musical goals.
How you discuss challenges and successes, areas for development and your musical and collaborative choices against the project's aims.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–3 descriptors. |
| 1–3 | Outlines challenges and successes; identifies development areas; states choices. |
| 4–6 | Describes; distinguishes development areas; demonstrates choices. |
| 7–9 | Explains; investigates development areas; justifies choices. |
| 10–12 | Discusses against the aims; examines development areas; evaluates choices. |
Reaching the top band: At each stage return to the musical goals in your plan: how far you met them, what went wrong, what you decided in your role and how it worked.
Your technical proficiency and musicianship in your identified role in the final product.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors. |
| 1–2 | Rudimentary technique; ineffective musicianship approximating the aims. |
| 3–4 | Inconsistent technique; sufficient musicianship transmitting the aims. |
| 5–6 | Competent technique; proficient musicianship realizing the aims. |
| 7–8 | Excellent technique; compelling musicianship personalizing the aims. |
Reaching the top band: Choose the passages where your own role is most audible and visible, so collaborators do not mask it.
How well the multimedia presentation is organized and presented.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|---|
| 0 | Does not reach level 1. |
| 1 | Ineffective. |
| 2 | Inconsistent. |
| 3 | Purposeful. |
| 4 | Resourceful and imaginative. |
Reaching the top band: Script the narration before editing so every segment answers how it relates to your goals.
For each criterion the teacher chooses the band that best matches the work overall. Not every point in a band has to be met; when the work sits in different bands on different points, the mark reflects the balance.
The upper mark goes to work that largely meets the band and is close to the next; the lower mark to work that meets it to a lesser extent. Only whole marks are given.
A high mark on one criterion does not imply high marks on the others. The top band does not require faultless work.
Your teacher meets you at each stage and authenticates the work, which is uploaded to the IB for assessment. Anything beyond the page or time limits is not assessed.
Want your Music IA read against these criteria? Contact us: a tutor will go through your plan or draft criterion by criterion and tell you where the marks are going.
Experimenting with music is out of 28 (A 6, B 8, C 6, D 8): 30% at SL, 20% at HL. HL also has the contemporary music maker, out of 32 (A 8, B 12, C 8, D 4), worth 30%.
Up to 1,500 words, excluding scores, images, the track list and bibliography, with up to 10 minutes of audio.
Both complete Experimenting with music; HL also completes the contemporary music maker, a 15-minute multimedia presentation of a real-life project.
No. The focus is the process and decision-making; excerpts demonstrate experimentation, not polished work.