IB Economics IA rubric: criteria A–F explained

The IB Economics IA is a portfolio of three commentaries, each on a news article published within the past year. Each commentary is marked on criteria A–E out of 14, and the whole portfolio on criterion F out of 3, for 45 marks in total. It is worth 30% at SL and 20% at HL.

Updated 2026-11-09

IB Economics IA at a glance

Total
45 marks (3 × 14 + 3)
Weighting
30% at SL, 20% at HL
Word limit
800 words per commentary
Recommended time
About 20 hours
Articles
One each from units 2, 3 and 4
Marking
Marked by your teacher, moderated by the IB
CriterionMarksWhat it assesses
A. Diagrams3 per commentaryWhether you construct and explain relevant diagrams.
B. Terminology2 per commentaryWhether you use appropriate economic terminology.
C. Application and analysis3 per commentaryWhether you apply and analyse economic theory in the context of the article.
D. Key concept3 per commentaryWhether you identify a key concept and link it to the article.
E. Evaluation3 per commentaryWhether your judgements are supported by reasoned argument.
F. Rubric requirements3 per portfolioWhether the whole portfolio meets the three rubric requirements, one mark each.
Total45 (14 × 3 + 3)

Criteria A–E are applied to each commentary separately; criterion F is applied once to the whole portfolio.

Based on the IB Diploma Programme Economics guide (current edition), section “Internal assessment criteria—SL and HL”. Band descriptions are summarised in our own words; follow the official guide your school provides.

A. Diagrams (3 per commentary)

Whether you construct and explain relevant diagrams.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Relevant diagram(s) included but not explained, or explained incorrectly.
2Relevant, accurate, correctly labelled diagram(s) with a limited explanation.
3Relevant, accurate, correctly labelled diagram(s) with a full explanation.

What the guide clarifies

  • Diagrams should match the article's situation, for example showing its price, tax or subsidy.
  • Diagrams, labels of five words or fewer and diagram headings of ten words or fewer are not counted, but the explanation is.

Where marks are lost

  • Incomplete labels on axes, curves or equilibria.
  • A generic textbook diagram unrelated to the article.
  • A diagram with no explanation in the text.

Reaching the top band: Put the article's figures and the direction of change on the diagram, then walk through the shift, the new equilibrium and the welfare effect, tying each back to the article.

B. Terminology (2 per commentary)

Whether you use appropriate economic terminology.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Relevant economic terminology is included.
2Relevant economic terminology is used appropriately throughout.

What the guide clarifies

  • Definitions and quotations must be in the body and count towards the word limit; footnotes are for references only.

Where marks are lost

  • Terms only at the start, with everyday language in the analysis.
  • Definitions hidden in footnotes to save words.

Reaching the top band: Define key terms briefly on first use, then use them consistently instead of everyday words.

C. Application and analysis (3 per commentary)

Whether you apply and analyse economic theory in the context of the article.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Relevant theory applied with limited analysis.
2Relevant theory applied throughout with appropriate analysis.
3Relevant theory applied throughout with effective analysis.

What the guide clarifies

  • The theory must come from the syllabus unit the article belongs to.
  • Each commentary explains the links between the article, a key concept and economic theory.

Where marks are lost

  • Long summaries of the article.
  • Correct theory that is detached from the article.

Reaching the top band: Start each analytical paragraph from a specific fact in the article, connect it to theory and follow the consequence, rather than explaining the textbook in general.

D. Key concept (3 per commentary)

Whether you identify a key concept and link it to the article.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1, or the key concept has already been used in another commentary.
1A key concept is identified with an attempt to link it to the article.
2A key concept is identified and the link is partially explained.
3A key concept is identified and the link is fully explained.

What the guide clarifies

  • Each commentary must use a different key concept. Repeating one in two commentaries risks 3 marks, in all three up to 6.
  • The nine key concepts are scarcity, choice, efficiency, equity, economic well-being, sustainability, change, interdependence and intervention.

Where marks are lost

  • Using intervention or efficiency in more than one commentary.
  • Naming the key concept in the header without linking it in the text.

Reaching the top band: Choose the key concept when you choose the article and carry it through the analysis and evaluation, not as a closing sentence.

E. Evaluation (3 per commentary)

Whether your judgements are supported by reasoned argument.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Judgements supported by limited reasoning.
2Judgements supported by appropriate reasoning.
3Judgements supported by effective and balanced reasoning.

What the guide clarifies

  • Commentaries should show economic insight into the implications of the article, discussing it as an economist would.

Where marks are lost

  • Listing pros and cons without a judgement.
  • A judgement with no support, or one-sided reasoning.

Reaching the top band: Weigh stakeholders, short and long run, advantages and limitations and the assumptions involved, then reach a clear, qualified judgement.

F. Rubric requirements (3 per portfolio)

Whether the whole portfolio meets the three rubric requirements, one mark each.

MarksWhat the work shows
0None met.
1One requirement met.
2Two requirements met.
3All three met.

What the guide clarifies

  • Each article is based on a different syllabus unit (Unit 2 microeconomics, Unit 3 macroeconomics, Unit 4 the global economy; not Unit 1).
  • Each article comes from a different, appropriate source.
  • Each article was published no earlier than one year before the commentary was written.

Where marks are lost

  • Two articles from the same outlet.
  • An article more than a year old.
  • Two microeconomics articles.

Reaching the top band: Before writing, list each article's unit, source and publication date and check all three rules. These are the easiest 3 marks in the portfolio.

How the IA is marked

Best fit

For each criterion the teacher chooses the band that best matches the work overall. Not every point in a band has to be met; when the work sits in different bands on different points, the mark reflects the balance.

Upper or lower mark in a band

The upper mark goes to work that largely meets the band and is close to the next; the lower mark to work that meets it to a lesser extent. Only whole marks are given.

Criteria are independent

A high mark on one criterion does not imply high marks on the others. The top band does not require faultless work.

Teacher-marked, IB-moderated

Your teacher marks the work against the published criteria, and the IB moderates a sample, which can move marks up or down.

Economics IA articles, word count and format

  • Each commentary has an 800-word limit, and moderators will not read beyond 800 words. Not counted: acknowledgments, contents page, diagrams, labels of five words or fewer, diagram headings of ten words or fewer, tables of statistical data, equations, formulae and calculations, in-text citations and references in footnotes or endnotes.
  • Articles may come from a newspaper, journal or the internet but not from television or radio. Ideally they are in the language of the commentary; otherwise include an accurate translation of the whole article and the original. Highlight the section you use if an article is long.
  • Each commentary records the article title, source (with access date for online articles), publication date, date the commentary was written, word count, syllabus unit and key concept used.
  • Students choose their own articles; the teacher may not hand articles to the class, and commentaries may not be written collaboratively. The same work cannot be used for both the IA and the EE.

Checklist before you submit

  1. The three articles cover units 2, 3 and 4, come from three different sources and were published within a year of writing.
  2. Each commentary uses a different key concept, carried through the text.
  3. Each has at least one fully labelled diagram tied to the article and explained step by step.
  4. Terms are defined in the body and used consistently.
  5. Analysis starts from facts in the article, with theory from the matching unit.
  6. Evaluation weighs stakeholders, time frames and assumptions and reaches a judgement.
  7. Each is within 800 words, with all seven cover details and the original article attached.

Get feedback on your IA

Want your Economics IA read against these criteria? Contact us: a tutor will go through your plan or draft criterion by criterion and tell you where the marks are going.

Frequently asked questions

How many marks is the IB Economics IA out of?

45 marks: each of three commentaries is marked on A–E out of 14 (diagrams 3, terminology 2, application and analysis 3, key concept 3, evaluation 3), plus 3 marks for criterion F across the portfolio. It is 30% of the grade at SL and 20% at HL.

What is the Economics IA word count?

800 words per commentary, and moderators stop reading at 800. Diagrams, short labels, data tables, calculations and references are not counted; definitions and quotations are.

Can two commentaries use the same key concept?

No. Each must use a different key concept; repeating one costs up to 3 marks under criterion D, or up to 6 if all three repeat.

What are the rules for Economics IA articles?

One article each from units 2, 3 and 4, from different sources, published no more than a year before you write, and not from television or radio.