IB ESS IA rubric: criteria A–F explained

The IB ESS IA is an individual investigation: you pose a research question on a local or global environmental issue, then collect and analyse data. Under the guide first assessed in 2026 it is marked on six criteria, A to F, for 30 marks: 25% at SL and 20% at HL, with the same requirements at both levels.

Updated 2026-11-09

IB ESS IA at a glance

Total
30 marks (criteria A–F)
Weighting
25% at SL, 20% at HL
Word limit
3,000 words
Recommended time
About 10 hours
Data
Primary or secondary, quantitative or qualitative
Group work
Up to three may collect data together; reports are individual
CriterionMarksWhat it assesses
A. Research question and inquiry4Whether you explain a local or global environmental issue with enough background research and state a focused research question.
B. Strategy4Whether you understand a strategy addressing an environmental issue and how tensions between perspectives affect its outcomes.
C. Method4Whether the method is repeatable and collects enough data to answer the question.
D. Treatment of data6Whether raw and processed data are communicated clearly, processed correctly and lead to findings that answer the question.
E. Analysis and conclusion6Whether you explain patterns and trends, consider bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty, and reach a supported conclusion.
F. Evaluation6Whether you evaluate specific limitations, improvements and unresolved questions in relation to the conclusion.
Total30

Based on the IB Environmental systems and societies guide (first assessment 2026), section “Internal assessment criteria—SL and HL”. Band descriptions are summarised in our own words; follow the official guide your school provides.

A. Research question and inquiry (4 marks)

Whether you explain a local or global environmental issue with enough background research and state a focused research question.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2An environmental issue described with errors or omissions; a question lacking focus or unlinked to the issue.
3–4The issue explained with enough background research to support the question; a focused question addressing the issue.

What the guide clarifies

  • Background research can be a literature review or a theory or model; citations must be traceable.
  • An unfocused question often cannot be answered within 3,000 words.

Where marks are lost

  • A question as broad as the effects of climate change.
  • Background with no references.

Reaching the top band: Start from a specific local issue, use two or three reliable sources for background and narrow it to a measurable question.

B. Strategy (4 marks)

Whether you understand a strategy addressing an environmental issue and how tensions between perspectives affect its outcomes.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2An existing or developing strategy linked to the question is stated; a tension between perspectives (economic, social, cultural, political or environmental) arising from it is described.
3–4The strategy is described; a tension between perspectives is explained.

What the guide clarifies

  • This criterion is new in the 2026 guide. The strategy's issue may differ from the one you investigate but must have a clear, credible link to the question.
  • Tensions arise from the conflicting goals and needs of groups with different viewpoints.

Where marks are lost

  • A vague strategy such as the government managing it better.
  • Naming perspectives without explaining the tension.

Reaching the top band: Choose a real strategy, such as a local plastic ban or protected-area plan, and spell out who gains, who loses and how that conflict shapes its outcome.

C. Method (4 marks)

Whether the method is repeatable and collects enough data to answer the question.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2A method that is not repeatable and does not yield enough data.
3–4A repeatable method that yields enough data to answer the question.

What the guide clarifies

  • Repeatable means enough detail for a third party to replicate it: set-up, your contribution, sampling or survey technique and how data are collected.
  • A purely literature-based review is not a repeatable method.

Where marks are lost

  • Saying a survey was sent with no sample or sampling detail.
  • A literature-only study.

Reaching the top band: Write the method as numbered steps with sample size, location, timing, instruments and controlled variables, ideally with a diagram.

D. Treatment of data (6 marks)

Whether raw and processed data are communicated clearly, processed correctly and lead to findings that answer the question.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2Data not communicated clearly; processing does not address the question; major errors.
3–4Clear communication; findings do not fully address the question; minor errors.
5–6Clear and detailed communication; findings fully address the question; correct processing.

What the guide clarifies

  • Clear includes labelled graphs and tables, units, decimal places and significant figures.
  • Minor errors that do not affect the conclusion do not prevent full marks.
  • Large raw data sets can be sampled in the text with the rest in an appendix.

Where marks are lost

  • Graphs without units or titles.
  • Processing unrelated to the question.

Reaching the top band: Show raw data, a worked processing example, a summary table and a suitable graph, each step aimed at the question.

E. Analysis and conclusion (6 marks)

Whether you explain patterns and trends, consider bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty, and reach a supported conclusion.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2Relevant patterns identified; the conclusion does not address the question or lacks support.
3–4Patterns described with some measures of bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty; conclusion addresses the question with partial support.
5–6All relevant patterns explained with measures of bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty; conclusion addresses the question with full support.

What the guide clarifies

  • A supported conclusion should include measures of bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty.

Where marks are lost

  • Describing trends without explaining them.
  • No mention of bias or uncertainty.

Reaching the top band: Add error ranges or a statistical test, discuss sampling bias explicitly and use these to judge how far the conclusion can be trusted.

F. Evaluation (6 marks)

Whether you evaluate specific limitations, improvements and unresolved questions in relation to the conclusion.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2Generic limitations, improvements and unresolved questions stated.
3–4Limitations and improvements described; unresolved questions outlined.
5–6Specific limitations and improvements evaluated; unresolved questions described as they affect the conclusion.

What the guide clarifies

  • Generic means applicable to many methods rather than yours.
  • Weaknesses concern control of variables or precision; limitations can concern the range of data, the system boundary or assumptions.

Where marks are lost

  • “Not enough time” or “small sample” without development.
  • Improvements that do not match the limitations.

Reaching the top band: For each limitation, state what it is, how much it affects the conclusion, a specific fix and what difference that fix should make.

How the IA is marked

Best fit

For each criterion the teacher chooses the band that best matches the work overall. Not every point in a band has to be met; when the work sits in different bands on different points, the mark reflects the balance.

Upper or lower mark in a band

The upper mark goes to work that largely meets the band and is close to the next; the lower mark to work that meets it to a lesser extent. Only whole marks are given.

Criteria are independent

A high mark on one criterion does not imply high marks on the others. The top band does not require faultless work.

Teacher-marked, IB-moderated

Your teacher marks the work against the published criteria, and the IB moderates a sample, which can move marks up or down.

ESS IA word count, format and group work

  • The limit is 3,000 words. Not counted: charts and diagrams, data tables, equations and calculations, citations and references in any form, the bibliography and headers.
  • The start of the report states the title, your personal code (for example xyz123), any group members' codes and the word count. No cover or contents page is needed.
  • Groups of up to three may design methods and collect data together, but each student has their own question, for example a different independent variable or different data from a shared set; reports are written individually and group reports are not allowed.
  • Your teacher advises once on one draft. The same work cannot be used for both the IA and the EE.

Checklist before you submit

  1. A focused, measurable question with referenced background research.
  2. A real strategy with the tension between perspectives explained.
  3. A step-by-step method a third party could repeat.
  4. Raw and processed data are clear, with units, labels and significant figures.
  5. Analysis discusses bias, reliability, validity and uncertainty.
  6. The conclusion answers the question and is supported by data.
  7. Evaluation is specific, with improvements matched to limitations and unresolved questions stated.
  8. Title, personal code and word count at the top; within 3,000 words.

Get feedback on your IA

Want your ESS IA read against these criteria? Contact us: a tutor will go through your plan or draft criterion by criterion and tell you where the marks are going.

Frequently asked questions

How many marks is the IB ESS IA out of?

Under the 2026 guide, 30 marks: A research question 4, B strategy 4, C method 4, D treatment of data 6, E analysis and conclusion 6, F evaluation 6. It is 25% at SL and 20% at HL.

What is the ESS IA word count?

3,000 words; charts, data tables, calculations and references are not counted.

Can I do my ESS IA with classmates?

Up to three students may collect data together, but each needs a distinct question and writes their own report.

What does the new ESS strategy criterion assess?

You describe a strategy addressing an environmental issue linked to your question and explain the tension between perspectives (economic, social, cultural, political or environmental) that it creates.