IB History IA rubric: criteria A–C explained

The IB History IA is a historical investigation in three sections: identification and evaluation of sources, investigation and reflection, marked on criteria A, B and C for 25 marks. It is worth 25% at SL and 20% at HL. Below, each criterion is broken down band by band.

Updated 2026-11-09

IB History IA at a glance

Total
25 marks (A 6, B 15, C 4)
Weighting
25% at SL, 20% at HL
Word limit
2,200 words
Recommended time
About 20 hours
Topic
Free choice, nothing from the last 10 years
Marking
Marked by your teacher, moderated by the IB
CriterionMarksWhat it assesses
A. Identification and evaluation of sources6Whether the question is appropriate, the sources relevant, and two of them analysed in depth for value and limitations.
B. Investigation15The investigation itself: organization, critical analysis focused on the question, effective use of evidence, evaluation of perspectives and a reasoned conclusion.
C. Reflection4What the investigation showed you about the historian's methods and challenges, explicitly connected to your own investigation.
Total25

Based on the IB Diploma Programme History guide (first examinations 2020), section “Internal assessment criteria—SL and HL”. Band descriptions are summarised in our own words; follow the official guide your school provides.

A. Identification and evaluation of sources (6 marks)

Whether the question is appropriate, the sources relevant, and two of them analysed in depth for value and limitations.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2The question is stated and appropriate sources are selected, with little or no explanation of their relevance; two sources are described but not analysed or evaluated.
3–4An appropriate question; some explanation of the sources' relevance; some analysis and evaluation of two sources, with limited reference to value and limitations.
5–6An appropriate, clearly stated question; appropriate, relevant sources with their relevance clearly explained; detailed analysis and evaluation of two sources, explicitly discussing value and limitations with reference to origin, purpose and content.

What the guide clarifies

  • The question must be phrased as a question.
  • The two sources can be primary or secondary; briefly explain each one's nature and relevance first.
  • The six key concepts (causation, consequence, continuity, change, significance, perspectives) are a good starting point for a question.

Where marks are lost

  • A question that is too broad, such as the causes of the Second World War.
  • Only one source evaluated, or both merely described.
  • Value and limitations not tied to your own question.

Reaching the top band: Work through origin, purpose and content for each source, and at each step say what that means for its value and limitations for your question, rather than generic claims of bias.

B. Investigation (15 marks)

The investigation itself: organization, critical analysis focused on the question, effective use of evidence, evaluation of perspectives and a reasoned conclusion.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–3 descriptors.
1–3Unclear, incoherent and poorly organized; little or no critical analysis, mostly generalizations and unsupported assertions; evidence mentioned but not analysed.
4–6Partially successful organization; mainly narrative or descriptive with limited analysis; evidence included but not integrated into the argument.
7–9Generally clear and well organized; some analysis that is not sustained; an attempt to integrate evidence; awareness of perspectives without evaluating them.
10–12Generally clear and well organized; critical analysis that may lack development; evidence from a range of sources supports the argument; some evaluation of perspectives; a reasoned conclusion.
13–15Clear, coherent and effectively organized; well-developed critical analysis focused on the question; evidence from a range of sources used effectively; perspectives evaluated; a reasoned conclusion consistent with the evidence and argument.

What the guide clarifies

  • No set structure is required, but the section must contain critical analysis focused on the question and a conclusion.
  • Primary sources, secondary sources or both may be used; investigations can be document-based, fieldwork-based (museums, sites, historic buildings) or local history.

Where marks are lost

  • Chronological narrative with no argument.
  • Long quotations without analysis.
  • Mentioning that some historians disagree without evaluating them.
  • A conclusion that does not follow from the argument.

Reaching the top band: Open each paragraph with a claim, support it with two or three specific pieces of evidence, set it against another historian's view and close by returning to the question.

C. Reflection (4 marks)

What the investigation showed you about the historian's methods and challenges, explicitly connected to your own investigation.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach the 1–2 descriptors.
1–2Some discussion of the historian's methods; little awareness of the challenges or limitations; the connection to the investigation is implied rather than explicit.
3–4Clearly focused on what the investigation showed about the historian's methods; clear awareness of challenges and/or limitations; a clear, explicit connection to the investigation.

What the guide clarifies

  • Possible prompts: which historian's methods did you use, and what were their limits? How do the historian's challenges differ from a scientist's or mathematician's? How can reliability be judged? What is the difference between bias and selection?

Where marks are lost

  • A general TOK essay unconnected to the investigation.
  • A personal diary of the research process.

Reaching the top band: Anchor every point in a specific moment from your investigation, such as how you handled two conflicting sources, then widen it to the historian's general problem.

How the IA is marked

Best fit

For each criterion the teacher chooses the band that best matches the work overall. Not every point in a band has to be met; when the work sits in different bands on different points, the mark reflects the balance.

Upper or lower mark in a band

The upper mark goes to work that largely meets the band and is close to the next; the lower mark to work that meets it to a lesser extent. Only whole marks are given.

Criteria are independent

A high mark on one criterion does not imply high marks on the others. The top band does not require faultless work.

Teacher-marked, IB-moderated

Your teacher marks the work against the published criteria, and the IB moderates a sample, which can move marks up or down.

History IA word count, structure and topic

  • The limit is 2,200 words, excluding the bibliography and references. Suggested split: about 500 words for sources, 1,300 for the investigation and 400 for reflection (a guide only).
  • The topic is free and need not relate to the syllabus, but it must be historical and not from the last 10 years. Your teacher must approve the topic and question before you start and check there are enough sources.
  • A bibliography and clear referencing are required. Your teacher advises once on one draft. The same work cannot be used for both the IA and the EE.

Checklist before you submit

  1. The question is phrased as a question with a specific time, place and focus.
  2. Both sources analysed in detail have their nature and relevance explained.
  3. Value and limitations are discussed through origin, purpose and content.
  4. Each investigation paragraph has a claim, evidence and analysis rather than narrative.
  5. At least two historical perspectives are evaluated, with your reasoned preference.
  6. The conclusion answers the question and matches the evidence.
  7. The reflection uses specific moments from your investigation to discuss the historian's methods and challenges.
  8. The work is within 2,200 words with a complete bibliography.

Get feedback on your IA

Want your History IA read against these criteria? Contact us: a tutor will go through your plan or draft criterion by criterion and tell you where the marks are going.

Frequently asked questions

How many marks is the IB History IA out of?

25 marks: A identification and evaluation of sources 6, B investigation 15, C reflection 4. It is 25% of the grade at SL and 20% at HL.

What is the History IA word count?

2,200 words, excluding the bibliography. The suggested split is about 500 words for section 1, 1,300 for section 2 and 400 for section 3.

Can I choose any topic for my History IA?

Yes, it need not relate to the syllabus, but it must be historical, not from the last 10 years, and approved by your teacher.

Is the History IA the same at SL and HL?

Yes. Both levels complete the same investigation against the same criteria; only the weighting differs (25% at SL, 20% at HL).