B. Investigation (15 marks)
The investigation itself: organization, critical analysis focused on the question, effective use of evidence, evaluation of perspectives and a reasoned conclusion.
| Marks | What the work shows |
|---|
| 0 | Does not reach the 1–3 descriptors. |
|---|
| 1–3 | Unclear, incoherent and poorly organized; little or no critical analysis, mostly generalizations and unsupported assertions; evidence mentioned but not analysed. |
|---|
| 4–6 | Partially successful organization; mainly narrative or descriptive with limited analysis; evidence included but not integrated into the argument. |
|---|
| 7–9 | Generally clear and well organized; some analysis that is not sustained; an attempt to integrate evidence; awareness of perspectives without evaluating them. |
|---|
| 10–12 | Generally clear and well organized; critical analysis that may lack development; evidence from a range of sources supports the argument; some evaluation of perspectives; a reasoned conclusion. |
|---|
| 13–15 | Clear, coherent and effectively organized; well-developed critical analysis focused on the question; evidence from a range of sources used effectively; perspectives evaluated; a reasoned conclusion consistent with the evidence and argument. |
|---|
What the guide clarifies
- No set structure is required, but the section must contain critical analysis focused on the question and a conclusion.
- Primary sources, secondary sources or both may be used; investigations can be document-based, fieldwork-based (museums, sites, historic buildings) or local history.
Where marks are lost
- Chronological narrative with no argument.
- Long quotations without analysis.
- Mentioning that some historians disagree without evaluating them.
- A conclusion that does not follow from the argument.
Reaching the top band: Open each paragraph with a claim, support it with two or three specific pieces of evidence, set it against another historian's view and close by returning to the question.