IB Maths IA rubric: criteria A–E explained

The IB Maths IA is a mathematical exploration, and AA and AI share one rubric: five criteria, A to E, 20 marks in total, worth 20% of the final grade. Criteria A–D are the same at SL and HL; criterion E, use of mathematics, has separate SL and HL descriptors. Below, each criterion is broken down level by level.

Updated 2026-11-09

IB Maths IA at a glance

Total
20 marks (criteria A–E)
Weighting
20% of the final grade (SL and HL)
Length
About 12–20 pages, double-spaced
Recommended time
About 10–15 hours of class time
Courses
Same for AA and AI
If not submitted
No grade for the course
CriterionMarksWhat it assesses
A. Presentation4The organization and coherence of the exploration: whether it is logically developed, easy to follow and meets its aim.
B. Mathematical communication4Whether mathematical language and representations are relevant, appropriate and consistent.
C. Personal engagement3How far you make the mathematics your own, thinking independently or creatively. It is not a measure of effort.
D. Reflection3How you review, analyse and evaluate the exploration, in the conclusion or throughout.
E. Use of mathematics6Whether the mathematics is relevant, commensurate with the course, correct and understood, with separate SL and HL descriptors.
Total20

Based on the IB Mathematics: analysis and approaches guide and Mathematics: applications and interpretation guide (first assessment 2021), section “Internal assessment criteria—SL and HL”, which is the same in both. Band descriptions are summarised in our own words; follow the official guide your school provides.

A. Presentation (4 marks)

The organization and coherence of the exploration: whether it is logically developed, easy to follow and meets its aim.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Some coherence or some organization.
2Some coherence and some organization.
3Coherent and well organized.
4Coherent, well organized and concise.

What the guide clarifies

  • Coherent means logically developed, easy to follow and meeting its aim, covering the overall structure and how the parts link.
  • Well organized means an introduction, a stated aim and a conclusion, with graphs, tables and diagrams in place in the text rather than in appendices, which are for large data sets and extra material.
  • Concise means no irrelevant or repetitive calculations, graphs or descriptions. Choosing analytic over technological methods is not a lack of concision; repeated calculations are.

Where marks are lost

  • No clear aim, or a conclusion that never returns to it.
  • Graphs and tables pushed into appendices.
  • The same calculation written out a dozen times.

Reaching the top band: State the aim and a route map at the start, close each section with a line on how it serves the aim, and show one worked example of a repeated calculation with the rest summarised in a table.

B. Mathematical communication (4 marks)

Whether mathematical language and representations are relevant, appropriate and consistent.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Some relevant mathematical communication, partially appropriate.
2Some relevant, appropriate mathematical communication.
3Relevant, appropriate and mostly consistent.
4Relevant, appropriate and consistent throughout.

What the guide clarifies

  • Use appropriate mathematical language (notation, symbols, terminology). Calculator or computer notation is acceptable only when software-generated.
  • Define key terms and variables where required.
  • Use multiple forms of representation (formulae, diagrams, tables, charts, graphs, models) where appropriate, and set out deductions and proofs logically.
  • Level 4 is possible with a single form of representation if it suits the topic; minor errors that do not impair communication are not penalised.

Where marks are lost

  • Calculator notation such as x^2, sqrt(x) or 3E-4 in the text.
  • Undefined variables, or notation that changes partway.
  • Graphs without labelled axes.

Reaching the top band: Define every variable and its units when it first appears, label every graph, keep one notation throughout, and search the final draft for stray * and ^.

C. Personal engagement (3 marks)

How far you make the mathematics your own, thinking independently or creatively. It is not a measure of effort.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Some evidence of personal engagement.
2Evidence of significant personal engagement.
3Evidence of outstanding personal engagement.

What the guide clarifies

  • Engagement can show as independent or creative thinking, presenting ideas your own way, exploring from different perspectives, and making and testing predictions.
  • The evidence must be in the work; a teacher's comment that you were engaged does not count.
  • Textbook-style explorations that reproduce readily available mathematics are unlikely to reach the higher levels.
  • Significant means a few authentic instances that drive the exploration; outstanding means numerous high-quality instances that drive it creatively.

Where marks are lost

  • An opening paragraph about loving the topic, followed by a textbook derivation.
  • Following a worked example from the internet step by step.

Reaching the top band: Work with your own data or your own question, and at each step record why you took it, what you expected and whether the result matched.

D. Reflection (3 marks)

How you review, analyse and evaluate the exploration, in the conclusion or throughout.

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Evidence of limited reflection.
2Evidence of meaningful reflection.
3Substantial evidence of critical reflection.

What the guide clarifies

  • Simply describing results is limited reflection.
  • Meaningful reflection links to the aim, says what was learned, considers a limitation or compares mathematical approaches.
  • Critical reflection considers what next, the implications of results, strengths and weaknesses of approaches and different perspectives, and often moves the exploration forward.
  • Substantial means critical reflection throughout; if it appears only at the end it must be high quality and show how it developed the exploration.

Where marks are lost

  • A single closing paragraph saying you learned a lot.
  • Restating results without evaluating the method.

Reaching the top band: After each result, add a sentence or two on what it means, where the method falls short and what another approach would give, and let that decide the next step.

E. Use of mathematics (6 marks)

Whether the mathematics is relevant, commensurate with the course, correct and understood, with separate SL and HL descriptors.

SL

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Some relevant mathematics is used.
2Some relevant mathematics; limited understanding is demonstrated.
3Relevant mathematics commensurate with the course; limited understanding.
4Commensurate mathematics, partially correct; some knowledge and understanding.
5Commensurate mathematics, mostly correct; good knowledge and understanding.
6Commensurate mathematics, correct; thorough knowledge and understanding.

HL

MarksWhat the work shows
0Does not reach level 1.
1Some relevant mathematics; limited understanding.
2Some relevant mathematics, partially correct; some knowledge and understanding.
3Commensurate mathematics, correct; some knowledge and understanding.
4Commensurate mathematics, correct; good knowledge and understanding.
5Correct mathematics showing sophistication or rigour; thorough knowledge and understanding.
6Precise mathematics showing sophistication and rigour; thorough knowledge and understanding.

What the guide clarifies

  • Relevant means mathematics that moves the exploration towards its aim; overly complicated mathematics where simple mathematics would do is not relevant.
  • Commensurate means syllabus-level or similar, not mainly prior learning; HL may go slightly beyond the syllabus, but that is not needed for the top levels.
  • Demonstrated is the key word: a correct answer or substituting into a formula does not show understanding.
  • Occasional minor errors are tolerated if they do not disrupt the mathematics; HL precise mathematics is error-free with appropriate accuracy throughout.
  • HL sophistication means HL content, or SL content used in a way beyond what an SL student could reasonably do; rigour means clear logic and language, with relevant claims justified or proven.
  • The mathematics only needs to serve the exploration: a few things done well beat many done poorly.

Where marks are lost

  • Mathematics that is mostly prior learning.
  • Formulae copied from the internet with no derivation or explanation.
  • GeoGebra or Desmos output with no interpretation.
  • Out-of-syllabus content added to look advanced but not understood.

Reaching the top band: Take one or two syllabus methods and go deep, showing the reasoning at every step; explain any technology output rather than just reporting it. At HL, include justification or proof of key claims.

How the IA is marked

Best fit

For each criterion the teacher chooses the band that best matches the work overall. Not every point in a band has to be met; when the work sits in different bands on different points, the mark reflects the balance.

Upper or lower mark in a band

The upper mark goes to work that largely meets the band and is close to the next; the lower mark to work that meets it to a lesser extent. Only whole marks are given.

Criteria are independent

A high mark on one criterion does not imply high marks on the others. The top band does not require faultless work.

Teacher-marked, IB-moderated

Your teacher marks the work against the published criteria, and the IB moderates a sample, which can move marks up or down.

Maths IA length and format

  • The report should be about 12–20 pages, double-spaced, including diagrams and graphs but excluding the bibliography. Quality of mathematical writing matters, not length. It can be typed or handwritten.
  • The cover page states the title and the number of pages. References are not assessed, but leaving them out may be flagged as an academic honesty issue; direct quotes must be acknowledged.
  • You may discuss ideas, share sources and give each other feedback, but each student writes their own exploration; where measurements are needed, each student collects their own data and explains any pooling.
  • Your teacher advises once on one draft and points out errors without correcting them. The same work cannot be used for both the IA and the EE.

Checklist before you submit

  1. The aim is stated at the start and the conclusion returns to it.
  2. Graphs and tables sit in the text, titled and labelled.
  3. Every variable is defined on first use and there is no calculator notation.
  4. Repeated calculations are shown once in full.
  5. You can point to at least three instances of personal engagement: your own data, question, method choices or predictions.
  6. Each main result is followed by reflection: meaning, limitations, alternative methods.
  7. The core mathematics is syllabus-level with reasoning shown at every step; technology output is interpreted.
  8. HL: key claims are justified or proven.
  9. The cover gives the title and page count, the body is about 12–20 pages and references are complete.

Get feedback on your IA

Want your Maths IA read against these criteria? Contact us: a tutor will go through your plan or draft criterion by criterion and tell you where the marks are going.

Frequently asked questions

How many marks is the IB Maths IA out of?

20 marks: A presentation 4, B mathematical communication 4, C personal engagement 3, D reflection 3 and E use of mathematics 6. The IA is 20% of the final Maths grade.

Is the Maths IA rubric the same for AA and AI?

Yes. Both courses use the same exploration requirements and criteria A–E; the difference is that the mathematics comes from your own course's syllabus.

How is the Maths IA different at SL and HL?

Criteria A–D are the same. Criterion E has separate descriptors: at HL, levels 5–6 require sophistication and rigour, and level 6 also requires precise, error-free mathematics.

How long should a Maths IA be?

About 12–20 pages, double-spaced, including graphs and excluding the bibliography. The guide stresses quality over length, and overly long work often loses marks for conciseness under criterion A.

What happens if I do not submit a Maths IA?

The guide states that a student who does not submit an exploration will not receive a grade for the course.